Loan Comparison Calculator: Which Offer Really Costs Less?
The lowest payment is not always the cheapest loan.
Two loan offers can look close until you add up the whole cost. A longer term lowers the monthly payment but adds interest, and a fee can wipe out a lower rate. Enter the amount, rate, term and fees for two loans and this calculator shows the monthly payment, the total interest and the full cost of each side by side, and which one is cheaper overall.
Your details
Try an example
Loan A
Loan B
Result
Loan A costs less overall
$1,242
Loan A $23,199 against Loan B $24,442 in total
- Loan A monthly payment
- $386.66
- Loan B monthly payment
- $287.40
- Monthly difference
- $99.26
- Loan A$23,199
- Loan B$24,442
Good to know: total cost = payment × months + fees
How it was worked out · notes
Payment = P × r ÷ (1 − (1 + r)^−n); total cost = payment × n + fees
- Loan A: $386.66 × 60 months = $23,199, plus $0 fees = $23,199.
- Loan B: $287.40 × 84 months = $24,142, plus $300 fees = $24,442.
- A lower payment with a longer term usually means more interest overall. Compare the total cost, not just the monthly figure, and check for early repayment charges.
The two loans side by side
| Loan A | Loan B | |
|---|---|---|
| Amount | $20,000 | $20,000 |
| Rate and term | 6.00% · 5 years | 5.50% · 7 years |
| Monthly payment | $386.66 | $287.40 |
| Total interest | $3,199 | $4,142 |
| Fees | $0 | $300 |
| Total cost | $23,199 | $24,442 |
Please note: Illustrative estimate based only on the numbers you enter. This is not financial, investment, tax or legal advice and not an offer of any product. Real products have fees, rate changes and rules this tool does not model. Check figures with your lender or a qualified, independent adviser before you decide.
The idea behind it
The idea behind the loan comparison calculator
01Term
Longer means lower payments, more interest
Spreading a loan over more months lowers each payment but means interest is charged for longer.
02Fees
Paid up front, counted once
Fees are added to the total cost so a cheap rate with a high fee can lose to a dearer rate with none.
03Total cost
The only fair comparison
Payment times months plus fees is the whole price of borrowing, and it is what separates two close offers.
One loan against five alternatives
Each row compares the same $20,000 loan at 6% over five years against a different alternative. The cheaper option is not always the one with the lowest rate, because the term and the fees both count.
| Alternative loan | Monthly payment | Monthly difference from Loan A | Cheaper overall |
|---|---|---|---|
| 5.5% over 5 years, $300 fee | $382.02 | $4.63 | Loan A |
| 5% over 7 years, $300 fee | $282.68 | $103.98 | Loan A |
| 6.5% over 4 years, no fee | $474.30 | $87.64 | Loan B |
| 4.5% over 7 years, $600 fee | $278.00 | $108.65 | Loan A |
| 7% over 3 years, no fee | $617.54 | $230.89 | Loan B |
Illustrative loans, not offers. Early-repayment charges, insurance and changes in rate are not included, so check the full terms before you sign.
Two loans, entered side by side
- Enter the amount, interest rate, term and fees for Loan A.
- Enter the same details for Loan B.
- Read which loan costs less overall and by how much.
- Check the side-by-side table for payments and interest.
A 5-year loan against a 7-year one
A $20,000 loan at 6% over 5 years costs about $386.66 a month and $3,199 in interest. The same amount at 5.5% over 7 years with a $300 fee costs about $287.40 a month but $4,442 in interest and fees, so the shorter loan is cheaper overall, by about $1,242, even though its payment is higher.
What is under the hood
Formula
total cost = payment × months + fees
Choosing on the monthly payment alone
- Choosing on the monthly payment alone.
- Ignoring fees, which can outweigh a lower rate.
- Comparing loans of different amounts.
- Forgetting early repayment charges.
Comparing loans, answered
Which loan is cheaper?
Compare the total cost, which is the payments plus fees, not just the rate or the monthly payment. A longer term can cost more even with a lower payment.
Why is the loan with the lower rate not always cheaper?
A longer term or a fee can add more than the lower rate saves. The total cost shows the full picture.
Can I compare different amounts?
Yes, but comparing the same amount is clearer. Different amounts change the total for reasons that have nothing to do with the offer.
Does it show APR?
No. It compares payments, interest and fees directly, which is easier to follow than a single APR figure.
Related tools
How we calculate this
We use the standard published formula or definition for this calculation, and we show the working so you can check it.
Spotted a mistake? Tell us and we'll check it. How we check our calculators