Rent vs Buy Calculator: Which Leaves You Better Off?
Compare the net worth each choice builds, not just the monthly cost.
Rent against buy is rarely just a question of which monthly payment is lower. Buying builds equity but costs money to buy, maintain and sell, while renting leaves your down payment free to earn a return. This calculator follows both paths month by month and compares what you would be left with after a set number of years. A chart shows when, if ever, buying pulls ahead.
Your details
Try an example
Assumptions
Result
Renting comes out ahead by
$21,574
after 10 years, counting the money a renter would invest
- Buyer's equity after selling
- $204,775
- Renter's savings
- $226,350
- Buying pays off after
- 16 years
- Buyer's equity
- Renter's savings
Good to know: buyer's equity = value × (1 − selling costs) − loan balance
How it was worked out · notes
Buyer's equity = home value × (1 − selling costs) − loan balance; renter's savings = (down payment + buying costs) invested, plus every month's difference in cost
- The loan is $280,000, paid over 30 years at 6.50%. After 10 years the home is worth $470,371 and $237,373 is still owed.
- Selling costs of 6.0% leave the buyer with $204,775.
- The renter keeps the $80,500 that would have gone into the purchase, invests it at 5.0%, and also invests whatever buying costs more than renting each month. That grows to $226,350.
- This is a simplified model. It leaves out income tax effects, moving costs, changes in rates and the value of living somewhere you control. Small changes to growth and return can flip the answer, so try a few.
Rent against buy at other time frames
Same assumptions. The result you chose is highlighted.
| After | Buyer's equity | Renter's savings | Better option |
|---|---|---|---|
| 5 years | $119,290 | $149,545 | Renting |
| 7 years | $151,463 | $179,314 | Renting |
| 10 years | $204,775 | $226,350 | Renting |
| 15 years | $309,406 | $311,231 | Renting |
| 20 years | $438,348 | $404,298 | Buying |
| 30 years | $798,569 | $613,701 | Buying |
Please note: Illustrative estimate based only on the numbers you enter. This is not financial, investment, tax or legal advice and not an offer of any product. Real products have fees, rate changes and rules this tool does not model. Check figures with your lender or a qualified, independent adviser before you decide.
The idea behind it
The thinking behind the numbers
01Equity
Buying builds a stake
Each payment reduces the loan, and any rise in the home's value adds to your equity, less the cost of selling.
02Opportunity
Cash has an alternative use
The down payment could earn a return elsewhere. Comparing both paths puts a price on that choice.
03Time
The longer you stay, the better it gets for buyers
Fixed buying costs are spread over more years, so a long stay usually favours buying.
Five rents against one home
The answer depends heavily on how much you would pay in rent. Each row prices the same $350,000 home with 20% down at 6.5% over ten years, and only the rent for a comparable home changes.
| Monthly rent | Renter's savings | Buying pays off after | Better option |
|---|---|---|---|
| Rent $1,200 | $331,869 | Over 30 years | Renting |
| Rent $1,500 | $279,109 | Over 30 years | Renting |
| Rent $1,800 | $226,350 | 16 years | Renting |
| Rent $2,200 | $156,004 | 6 years | Buying |
| Rent $2,800 | $50,485 | 3 years | Buying |
A simplified model. It ignores income tax effects and moving costs, and small changes to home price growth or investment return can flip the answer.
Two paths, one comparison
- Enter the home price, down payment, mortgage rate and term.
- Enter the monthly rent for a similar home and how long you will stay.
- Set the assumptions for tax, upkeep, price growth, rent rises, buying and selling costs and savings return.
- Read which option leaves you better off, and when buying pays off.
A $350,000 home against $1,800 rent
A $350,000 home with 20% down at 6.5% over 30 years, compared with $1,800 rent, leaves the buyer with equity of about $204,800 after 10 years and the renter with savings of about $226,400 under the default assumptions, so renting comes out ahead by about $21,600. At $2,800 rent, buying wins by about $154,000. Change the rent or the growth rate and the answer can flip.
The formula and reference values
Formula
buyer's equity = value × (1 − selling costs) − loan balance
Comparing only the monthly payment
- Comparing only the monthly payment against the rent.
- Forgetting buying and selling costs, which are large.
- Assuming prices only rise, or that investments always do.
- Ignoring maintenance, which typically runs around 1% of the value a year or more.
Rent against buy, answered
Is it cheaper to rent or buy?
It depends on the price, the rent, how long you stay and what your savings could earn. This calculator follows both paths month by month and compares what you are left with.
How long must I stay for buying to win?
The calculator shows the year when buying first pulls ahead. Buying and selling costs mean it often takes several years.
Why does the renter invest money?
The renter keeps the down payment and any monthly saving, and invests it at the return you set. Without that, renting would look cheaper than it is.
Does it include tax breaks?
No. Mortgage interest relief and other tax rules differ by country, so they are left out.
Related tools
- Mortgage Affordability CalculatorFind the home price you can afford from your income, debts, down payment and interest rate.
- Mortgage CalculatorMonthly payment & total interest
- Mortgage Overpayment CalculatorSee the interest and time you save by paying extra on your mortgage each month or in one lump sum.
- Amortization ScheduleFull loan payment breakdown
How we calculate this
We use the standard published formula or definition for this calculation, and we show the working so you can check it.
Spotted a mistake? Tell us and we'll check it. How we check our calculators