Story· Measures across borders
A factor of 4.45 lost a Mars probe. A factor of 2.2 emptied a jet's tanks.
Mars Climate Orbiter and the Gimli Glider came 16 years apart. Both turned on a number that was calculated correctly and read in the wrong unit.
Published · 4 min · By the Convert & Calculate team
Key takeaways
- Mars Climate Orbiter's thruster data was too small by a factor of 4.45, the number of newtons in a pound-force.
- Air Canada Flight 143 took on less than half its fuel because a density in pounds per litre was treated as kilograms.
- Neither factor is obscure. Both are on any conversion chart, which is why labelling units matters as much as converting them.
Mars Climate Orbiter: 1 pound-force = 4.45 newtons
NASA's mission page describes the cause as a failure to translate English units to metric. Launched in December 1998, the orbiter was lost on arrival on 23 September 1999.
According to Wikipedia's account of the mishap report, ground software supplied thruster impulse in pound-force seconds, while the navigation software expected newton-seconds. One pound-force is 4.448 newtons, so each value entered navigation about 4.45 times too small.
The orbiter was meant to pass 226 km above Mars. Later calculations put its path within 57 km of the surface.
Try it: Force
Open the full toolEnter a value
Result
1 kilogram-force =
9.80665 Newton (N)
1 Kilogram-force (kgf) × 9.80665 = 9.80665 Newton (N)
The working
- 1. Convert 1 Kilogram-force (kgf) to newtons: 1 × 9.80665 = 9.80665.
- 2. Convert to Newton (N): 9.80665 ÷ 1 = 9.80665.
Good to know: kgf is a legacy unit: 1 kgf = 9.80665 N — the weight of one kilogram in standard gravity.
1 Kilogram-force (kgf) in every unit
Kilogram-force (kgf) to Newton (N) conversion table
| Kilogram-force (kgf) | Newton (N) |
|---|---|
| 1 Kilogram-force (kgf) | 9.80665 Newton (N) |
| 2 Kilogram-force (kgf) | 19.6133 Newton (N) |
| 5 Kilogram-force (kgf) | 49.0332 Newton (N) |
| 10 Kilogram-force (kgf) | 98.0665 Newton (N) |
| 20 Kilogram-force (kgf) | 196.133 Newton (N) |
| 50 Kilogram-force (kgf) | 490.332 Newton (N) |
| 100 Kilogram-force (kgf) | 980.665 Newton (N) |
| 250 Kilogram-force (kgf) | 2,451.66 Newton (N) |
| 500 Kilogram-force (kgf) | 4,903.32 Newton (N) |
| 1,000 Kilogram-force (kgf) | 9,806.65 Newton (N) |
Typical forces
- Bite force, human
- 700 N
- Grip strength
- 500 N
- Car braking force
- 10,000 N
- Towing hitch rating
- 2,000 kgf ≈ 19.6 kN
- Mosquito wing thrust
- ~1 dyn
- Weight of 1 apple
- ≈ 1 N
The Gimli Glider: 1 kilogram = 2.2 pounds
On 23 July 1983, Air Canada Flight 143 needed 22,300 kg of fuel, as set out in the Gimli Glider account. The Boeing 767's fuel gauges were not working, so the crew measured the tanks by hand and converted litres to mass.
They used a density of 1.77, which was in pounds per litre, as if it were kilograms per litre. The correct figure was 0.803 kg per litre. Dividing 1.77 by 0.803 gives 2.2, the same factor as 2.205 pounds in a kilogram.
The aircraft ended up with 22,300 lb on board instead of 22,300 kg. In kilograms that is about 10,115 kg, less than half of what the flight needed. Both engines stopped at 41,000 ft, or about 12,497 m. The crew glided to a former air force base at Gimli, Manitoba, and all 69 people on board survived.
What the two have in common
| Incident | Year | Mixed up | Factor |
|---|---|---|---|
| Air Canada Flight 143 | 1983 | Pounds and kilograms | 2.205 |
| Mars Climate Orbiter | 1999 | Pound-force and newtons | 4.448 |
In both cases, the arithmetic worked and the number looked plausible. What failed was the assumption about what the number meant. A bare 1.77 gives no hint that it is in the wrong unit.
The habit that prevents this is simple: write the unit beside every number, and check it again whenever a figure moves from one person or system to another.
Methodology
We recalculated each factor with the exact definitions in our force and weight converters. Accident details come from the sources below and were not investigated independently. We could not read the text of NASA's mishap report directly, so the thruster and altitude details rest on Wikipedia's summary of it.
Run your own numbers with the Force tool.